How Much Stuffing Per Person For Thanksgiving

How Much Stuffing Per Person for Thanksgiving? Serving Guide

Last Updated on May 25, 2024 by Kimberlee Johnson

The stuffing is an essential aspect of Thanksgiving dinner that cannot be ignored. This warm and savory dish brings immense pleasure to our palates.

But how much stuffing per person for Thanksgiving? Well, let me tell you about a Thanksgiving I hosted last year. 

As I served my guests generous portions of stuffing, I learned a valuable lesson about portion sizes. 

So, keep reading, and I’ll share some practical tips to ensure everyone leaves your Thanksgiving feast feeling satisfied.

How Much Stuffing Does Each Guest Need For Thanksgiving?

Stuffing on a Baking Pan

Getting the right amount of stuffing for your Thanksgiving meal is important. You should aim to give each person about 3/4 cup of stuffing. 

You’ll need around 4 cups of stuffing if you have five guests. If your gathering is bigger with ten guests, prepare approximately 7-1/2 cups. 

“There is no sincerer love than the love of food.” 

George Bernard Shaw, Irish Playwright and Critic

This way, everyone gets enough to eat, and you won’t have many leftovers. Remember these numbers as you plan your Thanksgiving menu to ensure everyone leaves the table happy.

But how much gravy should each person get on Thanksgiving?

Is Stuffing Better to Put Inside Or Outside Turkey?

For a safer and easier approach, cooking stuffing outside is better, which we call “dressing.” Stuffing inside the turkey tastes great, but it makes the turkey take longer to cook evenly.

Plus, if you don’t do it perfectly, it can be risky for your health because of bacteria. So, to keep things simple and safe, make your stuffing outside the turkey. 

It’ll still be delicious without the cooking challenges and health worries.

How Much Stuffing Can You Put In Turkey?

When putting stuffing inside a turkey, you need to be careful. You should use approximately 1/2 to 3/4 cup of stuffing for every pound of turkey.

So, if your turkey weighs 12 pounds, you’d need around 6 to 9 cups of stuffing. But here’s the important part: using less stuffing is safer than stuffing the turkey too much. 

Why? Stuffing puffs up as it cooks and putting in too much might make the turkey cook unevenly and even be unsafe to eat. 

Find out what are the ten Thanksgiving foods here.

Does Stuffing Need To Be Moist Or Dry?

If you’re making stuffing for your turkey, keeping it moist, not dry, is important. Here’s why: moist stuffing helps heat kill bacteria more effectively during cooking, keeping your meal safe.

Once you’ve stuffed the turkey, put it in an oven set to at least 325°F right away. This ensures that both the turkey and the stuffing get cooked properly. 

To know exactly how long to cook it, check out a cooking chart with the right times for different turkey sizes. 

“The best Thanksgiving gatherings are those where the stuffing is just right – enough to satisfy, but leaving room for seconds and gratitude.”

Howkapow Gift Site

As such, remember moist stuffing and the right temperature make your Thanksgiving meal tasty and safe.

What Can You Put In The Stuffing To Make It Taste Better?

To make your stuffing taste amazing, add the right herbs and flavors. One way to do this is by using different herbs, like fresh sage, thyme [1], rosemary, and parsley. 

These herbs are like magic ingredients that make your stuffing delicious. You can mix and match them to find the taste you like best. 

So, whether you like rosemary’s earthy flavor or sage’s cozy feeling, herbs are the secret to turning your stuffing from okay to super tasty, making your Thanksgiving meal extra special.

What Kind Of Bread Works Best For Stuffing?

Turkey Stuffing

Picking the right bread for stuffing is like finding the perfect puzzle for your Thanksgiving meal. First, regular white sandwich bread is a safe bet – it soaks up flavors well. 

Challah is a bit fancy with a sweet and eggy taste. French or Italian bread gives your stuffing a nice mix of crunch and softness. 

Or try bagels for a chewy twist [2]. And there’s also Martin’s potato bread stuffing cubes, made especially for stuffing. 

Should The Stuffing Be Made The Day Before Thanksgiving?

Yes, it’s a good idea to make your stuffing before Thanksgiving, maybe even the day before, because it’s way more convenient. 

You won’t have to rush around on the big day trying to finish everything. Besides, the stuffing gets better when it’s made ahead of time. 

So, when you marinate meat, the flavors have time to mix and make the stuffing more delicious. 

Related Post: Basic Tips To Keep Food Warm For Thanksgiving


Can stuffing be left in a cooked turkey for a night?

No, it’s not safe to leave stuffing inside the cooked turkey. 

Stuffing the turkey introduces unnecessary food safety risks and should be removed before cooking and stored in a separate container.

What makes stuffing unhealthy?

Stuffing tends to be less healthy due to its high levels of fat, carbohydrates, and salt, making it a calorie-dense addition to your Thanksgiving meal.

How can you tell when the stuffing is done?

Use a food thermometer to measure this temperature, and it should reach a minimum internal temperature of 165°F (73.9°C), ensuring it’s thoroughly cooked and free from harmful bacteria.

In Summary

So, I’ve learned that planning for about 3/4 cup of stuffing for each person is a good idea. This way, everyone gets enough to eat, but you won’t have too much leftover stuffing. 

It’s a simple rule that makes preparing for Thanksgiving easier. There’s a debate about cooking the stuffing inside the turkey or separately. 

The safer and better choice is to make something called “dressing” that you cook separately. 

Even though stuffing inside the turkey tastes good, cooking can be tricky and unsafe if you don’t do it carefully.


Kimberlee Johnson
Follow me

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *